My Top 5 Songs of 2009: #1 “Cornerstone” by Arctic Monkeys
Friday, December 11th, 2009Those who know me will not be surprised by this choice. I have long been extolling the greatness of this band in general and this song particular.
For those who do not know, Arctic Monkeys exploded onto the UK music scene in 2005 and became the biggest act in England in forty years. Their debut album Whatever People Say I Am, That’s What I Am Not is a masterwork and their 2007 follow-up Favourite Worst Nightmare
showed growth that most bands take years to acquire. This year they released their third album Humbug
. Humbug is a bold departure from their earlier work. While still the hard indie rockin’ music they’re known for, the songs have an edge and heaviness not present in their earlier work.
Arctic Monkeys’ lead guitarist, vocalist, & songwriter Alex Turner has a lyrical complexity unseen in popular music today. His voice is one of the two things this band has over all others on the scene today (the other is drummer Matt Helders). But it’s Turner’s lyrics that set the songs apart.
Their Sheffield accents and very-UK references may make some of their songs hard to follow for US listeners and may require Wikipedia to get some of the names, places, and adjectives. (i.e., the word “something” is pronounced “summat” and rhymed accordingly).
“Cornerstone” is nestled in the back-half of Humbug. After the melancholy of “Crying Lightning” and “Fire and Thud,” it at first seems like a more upbeat number. But it quickly becomes apparent this may be the saddest song on the album. The protagonist journeys through various pubs (that’s what he’s naming at the top of each verse, not parts of a ship) looking for a girl he’s lost. In each he sees someone who looks like said lost girl and asks each if he can call them by said girl’s name. All turn him down in succession until he runs into the girl’s sister who consents.
There’s a lot to love here but I want you hear the song before I speak any further. So give it a listen.
At first you make think this is a creepy song about a dumped boyfriend simply obsessed with his ex. I would agree except for two facts. (1) The first girl is described as “close enough to be your ghost” and (2) the sister says “I’m really not supposed to”.
While you may argue some kind of sisterly love triangle, I think we’re dealing with deeper loss. This is a song about a man who’s girlfriend has died and he’s looking for some unhealthy comfort. The kind of comfort that he could only get from someone in as much pain as himself.
The songs ends right when he gets what he wants. No coda, no chorus repeat, his search is over. And the sad marches on.
Amazing.
p.s.
Click here to learn about Letraset.
Here’s an acoustic version which I love.

